Why Making Friends at 35+ is Harder Than Dating (And What to Do About It)
I was at Target yesterday, and I ran into another mom I know from school. We did that whole "Oh my gosh, hi! We should totally get coffee sometime!" dance, exchanged numbers again, and then… nothing. Just like the last three times.
How long since we promised to get coffee
Standing there in the toilet paper aisle, I had this moment of clarity: Making friends as an adult is absolutely ridiculous.
Think about it. When you were seven, friendship was simple. "Want to be friends?" "Sure!" Done. You'd be sharing your animal crackers within minutes.
But now? Now we're out here conducting elaborate social auditions, overthinking text response times, and somehow managing to make grabbing coffee feel like a bigger commitment than a mortgage application.
The MetroWest Friendship Reality Check
Here's what I've learned about adult friendship in our little corner of Massachusetts, and why it feels so impossibly complicated:
Everyone Already Has "Their People" (Or So It Seems)
Here's the thing about MetroWest: half the women seem like they've been friends since their kids were in diapers together. The other half went to college together and just happened to all end up in the same town.
But here's what I've learned - even those of us who grew up here are starting over. My childhood friends? Some moved away for jobs, others drifted apart as we became different people. Life happens, priorities shift, and suddenly you're 43 wondering when everyone else figured out how to maintain friendships through all the chaos.
The Scheduling Olympics
Remember when making plans meant "See you at 3"? Now it's a complex negotiation involving Google calendars, babysitter availability, work schedules, and the mysterious "family obligations" that seem to multiply after age 30.
I suggested a simple coffee date to someone last month. We're still trying to find a mutually available 45-minute window. At this point, I'm pretty sure we'll just run into each other at Target again first.
The Depth Dilemma
We're all starving for real conversation, but we're stuck in this weird small-talk purgatory.
"How's work?" "Fine, you?" "Good, good." Awkward pause "Well, I should probably…"
Meanwhile, what we're really thinking is: "I just had a hot flash in the frozen foods aisle and I'm pretty sure I'm entering perimenopause but I have no idea who to ask about it because all my close friends moved away after college."
But instead we talk about the weather. Again.
What I Wish Someone Had Told Me About Adult Friendship
It's Not Just You
That woman who seems to have it all together? She's probably also wondering why making friends feels so hard. The mom who's always organizing playdates? She might be doing it because she's lonely too.
The truth is: Almost everyone is looking for deeper connections. We're just all terrible at admitting it.
Quality Over Quantity (Finally)
Here's the silver lining of adult friendship being so complicated: You get really good at figuring out who's worth the effort.
At 22, I would have drinks with literally anyone who asked. Now? I'm protective of my time and energy. I want friends who get my sense of humor, don't judge me for having a messy house, and can handle real conversations about real things.
Proximity Isn't Everything
Just because someone lives in your neighborhood doesn't mean you'll be best friends. Just because your kids are the same age doesn't mean you'll click. And that's okay. Sometimes your person is where you least expect them.
The Friendship Fix:
5 Strategies That Actually Work
So how do we actually make this work? Here are the 5 strategies I've learned (mostly through trial and error):
1: Start Small and Be Specific
Instead of "We should get coffee sometime," try "I'm going to that new coffee shop on Main Street Thursday morning around 9. Want to join me?"
Specific plans happen. Vague intentions don't.
2: Lead with Authenticity
Skip the "How are you?" opener. Try "I just spent 20 minutes looking for my keys while holding them" or "Please tell me you also have no idea what's happening at school pickup."
Real moments create real connections.
3: Use the Magic of Shared Experiences
Instead of one-on-one coffee dates (which can feel like interviews), try:
Walking groups
Farmers market wandering
Local events where you have something to talk about
Seasonal activities that give you a natural reason to hang out
4: Find Your "Third Places"
You know those spots where you see the same people regularly? The gym, the coffee shop, the library? Those are friendship goldmines. Say hi to the same person three times, and you're practically neighbors.
5: Embrace the Slow Burn
Adult friendship is like a good wine (or a decent coffee) – it takes time to develop. Don't expect instant best friends. Focus on building consistent, low-pressure connections.
It's Actually Worth It
Here's what nobody tells you about the ridiculousness of adult friendship: When you find your people, it's better than anything you had in your twenties.
These friendships are chosen, not convenient. They're based on who you actually are now, not who you were in college. And they're built on mutual respect for each other's complicated, messy, beautiful lives.
The woman who texts you at 2 PM on a Tuesday just to say "Today is hard" and doesn't expect you to fix it? That's gold.
The friend who shows up with coffee when you're having a rough week? That's everything.
The group text that makes you laugh until you cry about the absurdity of suburban life? That's what we're all looking for.
Your Turn, MetroWest
So here's my challenge to all of us:
Let's stop pretending adult friendship isn't weird and start embracing the weirdness.
Next time you're at the grocery store thinking "She seems nice," say something. Not "We should get coffee," but "I love your jacket, where did you get it?"
Next time someone suggests plans, say yes before your brain has time to come up with seventeen reasons why it won't work.
Next time you're feeling lonely, remember that half the women around you are probably feeling the same way. We just need to start talking about it.
Because the truth is, we're all just grown-ups who sometimes eat cereal for dinner and wonder if we're doing this whole life thing right. And that's exactly why we need each other.
What's your biggest adult friendship challenge? Drop a comment below – I bet other women are dealing with the same thing.
P.S. If you're reading this and thinking "I wish I knew more women like this," you're already in the right place. Welcome to the community where we talk about real things and support each other through the beautiful mess of MetroWest life.
Want more real talk about life in MetroWest? Join our Facebook group where we share local recommendations, plan meetups, and have the conversations that matter.
RELATED POSTS
Coming Soon to The Social Sip:
"The Introvert's Guide to Making Friends in MetroWest"
"Where to Meet Women in MetroWest (That Isn't School Pickup)"
"Red Flags in Adult Friendship (And How to Handle Them)"
"Building Your Social Circle When You're New to MetroWest"
Connect with Adventures & Lattes:
Instagram: @adventureslattes
Email: helloadventuresandlattes@gmail.com
DISCLOSURES & TRANSPARENCY
About Adventures & Lattes: This blog is part of Adventures & Lattes, a MetroWest Massachusetts women's community focused on connections and local discoveries. We may feature local businesses and services that align with our community values.
Health & Wellness Note: This blog may occasionally reference personal health experiences including perimenopause, mental health, and wellness topics. These are shared for community connection and relatability, not as medical advice. Always consult healthcare professionals for personal health concerns.
Community Guidelines: All recommendations shared are based on experiences and community feedback. We will always disclose any partnerships or sponsored content clearly.
Privacy Note: While we love sharing stories and experiences, we always protect the privacy of our community members. Any personal anecdotes shared have been used with permission or details have been changed to maintain anonymity.
Local Focus: This content is specifically created for women in the MetroWest Massachusetts area, including but not limited to: Natick, Framingham, Wellesley, Needham, Newton, Waltham, Wayland, Sudbury, Hopkinton, Ashland, Holliston, Westborough, Marlborough, Acton, Concord, Hudson, Maynard, Watertown, and Weston.